Kw-logo-smaller

Should You Have to Dissect?

Who knows what she's dissecting?
Is Dissection Cruel?

Do you cringe when your science teacher tells you what animal you'll be dissecting this year? When the big day comes to cut apart that animal in the name of science do you suddenly come down with a fake illness or do you arrive early to class? Personally, I didn't think dissecting animals was gross, but a lot of my friends did.

Not everybody has the heart to take a sharp blade and slice open the stomach of a frog, grasshopper or baby pig. Just the thought of poking through body parts has sent a weak-stomached student running in terror. What I don't understand is, what's the big deal? It's science class and you're there to learn science. The anatomy of animals is part of the learning experience.

The first animal I dissected was a grasshopper. The girl next to me watched in horror as I pulled its legs apart as far as they would go and then pinned them to the tray. The grossest part of the entire process was the smell of formaldehyde. That's the chemical that preserves the animals while they sit.

I understand that everyone doesn't consider it fun to cut apart some animal. However, how else are you going to learn? Sure you can draw pictures, but it's not the same. Besides, it's not like you have to kill the animal yourself. It's already dead. All those animals were collected for scientific purposes. Even if you don't want to be dissecting something you would never eat, it's good to know how that animal functions. There might come a day when you have the chance to rescue a frog and if you don't dissect one in science class, you're not gonna know what to do. (Okay, so maybe that's a stretch!)

To find out what Kidzworld members have to say about the topic of dissection, click here.

Related Stories:
>
>

readers voted!

Comments

racecar44

racecar44 wrote:

e,o
commented: Wed Apr 10, 2013

brunostar

brunostar wrote:

e.o
commented: Wed Apr 10, 2013

imagine994

imagine994 wrote:

I Know it's for school and that but seriously.. Y? I, personally love animals and I thi...
commented: Sun Mar 31, 2013

there are 7 more comments

Please login or register to add comments


like this article?
Sign up now to get more just like!

latest videos

F1045857839687

Is Dissection Cool or Cruel? Vote!

  • I think it's super cool!
  • Cruel. I would never disect something.
  • I'm undecided.

related stories

More than 1.8 million people support PETA, making it the world's largest animal rights organizati...
High school dissection is a hotly debated science topic among high school students and teachers. ...
A new school year means new classroom dilemmas -- like whether or not to dissect. Here are some ...

Random in the forums

woahitskar
woahitskar posted in Debating:
"AlphaT" wrote: "Teh_Skittlez" wrote: "AlphaT" wrote: "Teh_Skittlez" wrote: "AlphaT" wrote: "Teh_Skittlez" wrote: Right, I'm obligated to sign up for the draft, and you couldn't even if you wanted to. Then again, women couldn't own and manage land while married until 1718....and it wasn't national until around 1850. You should probably specify where, because the place where I live wasn't even colonized yet in 1718.  Providence of Pennsylvania. However most states didn't accept it until around 1840-50. Maryland had achieved statehood in 1788, but it took them until 1841 to legalize married women to own property, and even them they had no control over the property. This is the case for many states. Face it, early America treated women as property....she was right on that part. But that's all changed. I'm not denying it. I was merely suggesting that you should specify where. Of course, in all the dates you've listed so far, men were also to be bought and sold as property in the U.S. in the states that would become the Confederacy. I would say that their treatment as property was much harsher than that of women in many cases, but yes, of course both men and women have been treated as property by the law in the past, and still are in many places today.    American Slavery didn't discriminate between genders. And for women, it was the same for blacks and whites. Also, pinning slavery and the confederacy together? I thought you knew more about the topic. But that's another debate.
reply 1 minute
american_brit
american_brit posted in Debating:
"arthi" wrote: "Teh_Skittlez" wrote: "american_brit" wrote: "Pokemaster235" wrote: YES! WE women have been neglected for too long!!! I wouldn't necessarily say that. The fight for women's rights has gone on and those for feminist  rights seem to have won. Sure, there is no way to fully promote equal rights, but when it comes to women's place in society -at least in places such as the United States and European countries and in many other regions- it's been on a more leveled playing field with men.  So here? Here where I am? I'm satisfied. I don't believe that women's rights have been neglected. In some ways, they're held above those of men. But out there? Beyond the borders of my "humble" dwelling, there are some problems. Women are abused and seen as lesser. (I'm trying to put this in nicer terms. I don't think it's working... :/)  I think we need to work on fixing those, instead of complaining about how we're deprived as our rights. Because honestly? We have no idea how bad it is.  Sorry,  I went on a mini tangent.  I think your tangent was very good. You seem to have a pretty solid grasp of the situation, and you also are capable of expressing it well. Great post, great job. Agreed. Thanks guys (:
reply 4 minutes
-Gwen42--
-Gwen42-- posted in General:
Gwen. (My name.)
reply 4 minutes
woahitskar
woahitskar posted in General:
Fiona. 
reply 6 minutes
wicked13
wicked13 posted in General:
sorry.... but you don't. . . . I do (again)
reply 13 minutes

play online games

Candy-100

A great online version of the famous Candy Crush. This is the best game launched...

1515_gl_kidzworld_100x100_jpg_fz

Intriguing planets, weird and wonderful characters; challenge friends and find a...

157262_(2)

When you go back to Candyland, you’ll wonder why you ever left in the first plac...

100x100_ra_logo_girl

Uncle George has left you his farm, but unfortunately it’s in pretty bad shape. ...

_thumb_100x100

Shoot blobs with different properies to merge yellow blobs. Your blobs can be re...