Did LeBron Make the Right Move?

Jul 20, 2014

LeBron James, basketball's brightest star, its best player, the poster boy for greatness and the lightning rod for criticism, decided to leave a Miami Heat squad he had taken to four straight Finals (two wins) and return home to Cleveland to the state he was born in and the team he so cruelly abandoned four years ago. But did he make the right choice?

Did LeBron Make the Right Move?Did LeBron Make the Right Move?Courtesy of NBA


When the Heat fell to the Spurs in the Finals people were happy that "team" basketball had prevailed. Gregg Popovich and his collection of veterans, foreign-born all-around players and cast offs had defeated mighty Miami, who looked one-dimensional, tired and overmatched in the half court. Most of all Dwyane Wade looked average, Bosh looked deferential, and the team looked very beatable. After the season, LeBron opted out of his contract, as did Dwyane Wade and CB4, and the rumblings began that maybe the Heat might be disbanding.

I can't watchI can't watchCourtesy of SFGate

The Decision: Part 2 

The Cavs were an afterthought. Anybody who says they knew he would sign there is lying. After what LeBron did to them when he left for the Heat in 2010, and the letter his owner wrote, eviscerating him for his actions, LeBron ending up in Cleveland was a blogosphere fantasy, a radio talking point that nobody really took seriously. Then it happened. Sports Illustrated had exclusive rights to the essay in which LeBron explained why he was returning to Cleveland, and the Internet exploded with the news. LeBron was coming home to Cleveland. Crazy.

Tell the World That I'm Coming HomeTell the World That I'm Coming HomeCourtesy of SI


People hated LeBron for what he did to Cleveland, not the least of which the people of Cleveland. They burned his jersey, defaced murals with his face on them and took to Internet message boards to voice their disdain for "King James". Would they welcome him back with open arms? Yes, yes they would. And they did, putting up banners marking the return of the King and praising his decision to let bygones be bygones with owner Dan Gilbert and return home to try and win a championship. Media pundits lauded his decision and the court of popular opinion exonerated LeBron for all past crimes. 

But Can They Win?

The short answer is yes, but their roster is raw with young talent. They have Kyrie Irving, one of the most dynamic young PGs in the game, and Dion Waiters, a player with reported attitude problems but undeniable talent. They also have Anthony Bennett and Tristan Thompson, two big-men who are only getting better, not to mention Anderson Varejao, the perpetually-injured Brazilian who has seemingly endless energy when on the floor. Oh yeah, and Andrew Wiggins, the No.1 overall draft pick from this year who is an athletic freak. Their new Head Coach, David Blatt, comes with an international resume a mile long. They also might swing a deal for Kevin Love, one of the 10-12 best players in the NBA. So yeah, they can win. But was it right the right decision to leave the Heat? If the idea is too be popular and win over the world, then it was definitely the right decision. All the LeBron haters have been silenced. If his goal is to catch MJ for championships and challenge for greatest of all time, then the answer is a little more unclear. 

Have your say!

Do you like how LeBron went back to the Cavs? Do you think they can win the Championship this season? Next season? Let us know your opinion in the comments section.



readers voted!



aaronfreefro wrote:

turn up LeBron and kyrie and love im a.cavs fan fr fr
commented: Wed Oct 15, 2014

I think he made the right choice for the cavs but not for the heat. the heat is gonna b...
commented: Fri Oct 03, 2014

that was no the smart move. 2 rings miami heat. 0 rings clevend cavailers
commented: Sun Aug 24, 2014

there are 24 more comments

Please login or register to add comments

like this article?
Sign up now to get more just like!

latest videos


What Tattoo Does Lebron James Have?

  • His mom's name, Gloria.
  • A Nike Swoosh.
  • A Cleveland Cavalier's logo.
  • A basketball.

related stories

The veteran-led San Antonio Spurs take on Lebron James and the Miami Heat in a rematch of last ye...
Jason Collins is a professional basketball player in the NBA. He's not a Superstar or anything, h...
Dwight Howard has had a long great NBA career full of ups and... ups! He's one of the most belove...
Basketball has come a long way. The game has evolved from an awkward dorky game with no dribbling...
Most people only know LeBron James as an NBA star - the youngest MVP in the history of the league...
Witness! It didn't take long for Lebron James to live up to his hype. Kidzworld checks out King J...

Sports in the forums

They beat the Bengals 27-0, and Reggie Wayne is the 9th player in NFL history to get 14,000 pass yards!!!
reply 25 minutes
"Justin_A00" wrote:Thank you, some one who finally understands!!! i love marching band (im on the drumline) and i hate it when people call it "gay" or "stupid" and when people say that its not a sport, if they joined, they would understand. marching band is the best I'm on flute and it's really hard to march 54 sets and memories 221 measures of music!!!!!! 
reply about 2 hours
what all tricks or stunts can you do with your rollers ;) ????????  :) ;) :hippie :D
reply about 12 hours
Talladega Results: 1.) Timothy Peters #17 2.) Taylor Malsam #32 (Best Career Finish) 3.) Spencer Gallagher #23 (Best Career Finish) 4.) Tyler Reddick #19 5.) Ryan Blaney #29 POINTS: 1.) Matt Crafton #88 2.) Ryan Blaney #29 3.) Darrell Wallace Jr. #54 4.) Johnny Sauter #98 5.) Joey Coulter #21 (SURPRISE)
reply 2 days
"ParadiseHeart" wrote: "11rainbow" wrote: you are braging  Haha I think so too. But good for you girl. There's nothing wrong with bragging about achievements. It's a happy thing and should be talked about. Also congrats to the OP. 
reply 2 days

play online games


A great online version of the famous Candy Crush. This is the best game launched...


Have you ever fancied being a ranger like those fantasy characters you love so m...


You run across the city in a car chase with the police officers.


The evil master kidnapped all of your friends!


Explore the world or hang out with friends in your own condo. Get a unique look,...