Dear Dish-It: My Friend Cuts Herself ... & Lies About It

Dear Dish-It,

My friend used to lie about little things like she could play guitar hero on expert when she couldn't even play easy, and what jean size she is. Now she's lying about things me and my other friend are getting concerned about. She said at a sleepover that she cuts herself with glass, and we didn't believe her, so we checked on the back of her hands and there were a few scars. Then she said she was kidding - but we don't like her kidding about serious things. Later she told us that she cuts again. Again we checked her hands; there were more scars. Each time we tell her to stop, she says it was her cat. But her mom told us they don't have a cat! I'm getting scared that she might cut too deep or try to kill herself or something.


Dear ......,

It can be hard to understand why a friend might injure herself on purpose. Cutting - using a sharp object to cut your own skin on purpose until it bleeds - is a form of self-injury. Some people turn to this behavior when they have problems or painful feelings and haven't found another way to cope or get relief. Most of the time, people who cut themselves don't talk about it or let others know they’re doing it. But sometimes they confide in a friend. Sometimes a friend might find out in another way. I'm not sure whether or not your friend is lying, but since she told you she cuts herself, you need to take that seriously. Here is some more information about cutting that may help you help your friend.

Your Feelings

It can be upsetting to learn that a friend has been cutting. You might feel confused or scared. You may feel sad or sorry that your friend is hurting herself in this way. You might even be mad - or feel like your friend has been hiding something from you. You might wonder what to say, whether to say anything at all, or if there is anything you can do to help a friend who cuts. It can help you to know more about cutting, why some people do it, and how they can stop. Sharing this information with your friend can be a caring act, and it might help her take the first step toward healing.

Understanding why a friend may be cutting can help you be supportive. But what can you actually do to help your friend stop? The first thing is to be realistic about what you can achieve: as with any damaging behavior, some people just may not be ready to acknowledge the problem and stop. So don't put too much pressure on yourself - your friend's problem could be a longstanding one that requires help from a professional therapist or counselor. Therapists who specialize in treating adolescents often are experienced in working with people who self-injure and can also help with other issues or emotional pain they might have.

How To Help

Here are some things that you can try to help a friend who cuts:

  • Talk about it: You've asked about the cuts and scratches - and maybe your friend changed the subject. Try again. Let your friend know that you won't judge and that you want to help if you can. If your friend still won't talk about it, just let her know the offer stands and you are open to talking anytime. Sometimes it helps to let a friend know that you care. Still, even though you do your best, your friend might not want to talk.
  • Tell someone: If your friend asks you to keep the cutting a secret, say that you aren't sure you can because you care. Tell your friend that she deserves to feel better. Then tell an adult in a position to help, like your parents, a school psychologist or counselor, or a teacher or coach your friend is close to. Getting treatment may help your friend overcome the problem. Your friend may be mad at you at first. But studies show that 90% of those who self-injure are able to stop within a year of beginning treatment.
  • Help your friend find resources: Try to help your friend find someone to talk to and a place to get treatment. There are also some good books and online support groups for teens who self-injure. Be careful, though: although some websites offer useful suggestions about how to resist the urge to cut, the stories or pictures some people send in may actually trigger the urge to cut in those who read or see them. And some sites promote a sense of sisterhood or solidarity that might interfere with a person's getting help. There's nothing cool about cutting - beware of people or websites that suggest there is!
  • Help your friend find alternatives to cutting: Some people find that the urge to self-injure passes if they squeeze an ice cube in their hand really hard, draw with a red marker on the body part they feel like cutting, take a walk with a friend (you!), rip up old newspapers, play loud music and dance, or find another distraction or outlet for their feelings. These strategies don't take the place of getting professional counseling, but they can help in the short run.
  • Acknowledge your friend's pain: Let friends who cut know that you get what they're going through by saying things like, "Your feelings must just overwhelm you sometimes. You've been through a lot - no wonder you hurt. I want to help you find a way to cope that won't hurt you anymore." Try to avoid statements that send the message you don't take your friend's pain seriously (such as "But you've got such a great life" or "Things aren't that bad," which can feel dismissive to a person who cuts).
  • Be a good role model: Everyone experiences painful emotions like hurt, anger, loss, disappointment, guilt, or sadness. These emotions are part of being human. Coping with strong emotions - instead of dwelling on them and continuing to feel bad - involves a few key skills, like knowing how to calm yourself down when you're upset, putting feelings into words, and working out solutions to everyday problems. Be the kind of person who can do this and your friend will learn from you.

What if I Try to Help & She Says No?

It's often hard to help a friend who cuts. You may not see changes overnight, if at all. Some people aren't ready to face what they're going through - and you can't blame yourself for that. Some people might not be ready to ask for or receive help with their troubles. You can encourage a friend to get help, but your friend might not open to the idea, at least not right away. You might need to be patient. A friend could need time to think about what you've said.

People react in different ways when someone tries to help. But don't be afraid to try to help a friend. Sometimes your honest concern is just what a person needs. By reaching out, you might just help someone take the first step toward healing. Sometimes when you try to help, your friend might be angry or say you don't understand. Or the friend might really appreciate that you care but still not be ready to accept help.

It's natural to feel helpless, worried, sad, or upset - especially if you feel you're the only one who knows what a friend is going through. Sometimes it helps to confide in an adult you trust about the situation. It can be really hard when a friend just won't let you help. But don't take on the burden as your own or feel responsible for someone else's behavior. Sometimes even the truest friend may need to take a break from an intense situation. Be sure to care for yourself and don't allow yourself to be drained or pulled down by your friend's situation.

For more help or info on cutting, check out S.A.F.E. Alternatives (Self-Abuse Finally Ends) at, or call their toll-free line at 1-800-DONT-CUT (1-800-366-8288).

Related Stories:

latest videos


Do You Know Someone Who Cuts?

  • Yeah, one of my friends cuts herself/himself.
  • I have had issues with cutting.
  • I don't know anyone personally, but I've heard of people who do it.
  • No, I don't know anyone who cuts.

related stories

Cutting is a type of self-injury that is a serious problem. If you cut, or know someone who does,...
When does a normal bad day turn into serious depression? Get the facts you need to recognize, and...
At times, we all feel bad or overwhelmed with our world, our friends, and our life. But let me te...

Dear Dish-It in the forums

EndlessDream posted in Friends:
Hmmm....Then she mustn't be necessarily "using" you, if she is not getting something in return ( As far as we know of). However, It does sound like she is being extremely unfair. That just might be how she is. Not exactly loyal to anyone. Well, try to talk to her about it and tell her how you feel. And, if it doesn't work out, then she might not be a great friend to hang around with, and maybe you will find someone else who enjoys your company. I hope this helps, and good luck :)
reply about 18 hours
XxIHateMathxX posted in Friends:
No not really. Like I said, one minute she's all smiley and then she doesn't even look at me. Most of the time I see her with Daniela and Andrea. Today she was asking me if I was going to hang out with her, Daniela, Andrea and Luisa during recess. When I told her that I was 'going to have to think' she was like, "Whatever." and ran off to catch up with the Threesome. Thanks. :)
reply about 18 hours
EndlessDream posted in Friends:
Is she asking you to do things for her? Like help with homework, carry her books and so on?
reply about 18 hours
XxIHateMathxX posted in Friends:
This is gonna be long:   I have this 'friend' Amelia. She and I bonded really fast last year and we've become inseparable.   But lately she's blowing me off and my other best friend Belen told me: Amelia is actually using you. She does this to new kids at school, especially from foreign countries. She thinks because you're Chinese and the Chinese teacher's daughter, you'll help her. She's also using you as a backup friend - a substitute. There's this new girl Daniela, who Amelia thinks is her new best friend. She thinks that when Daniela stop hanging out with her, she'll have you.   The thing is, Daniela is pretty nice and she probably doesn't know all the trouble she's causing. Belen's old 'best friend' Andrea is doing the same to her.   I also learned that Amelia is seemingly the 'most popular girl in school' because she's mean to everyone. She always passes by the little kids' classrooms and hugs them & stuff. They seem to love her, but now I know it's because they think if they're nice they won't get bullied.   Maybe she WAS using me but I dunno. Belen says that each kid in the entire school has a bad story about Amelia and something she did to them. I said, "Then how was she so nice to me last year?" Then Belen was all like, "She was using you."   I don't know if she's telling the truth. She and Amelia are deadly enemies and she might be making up the whole Amelia story just to get back at her. Although Amelia has been dropping a few signs that she IS using me as a substitute friend.   Sometimes when I walk in, she'll be like "OOOOHHH! CASSANDRA! HI! HOW ARE YOU! C'MON, LOOK AT THIS! WE'RE GONNA HAVE SOOOO MUCH FUN TOGETHER ..."   And other times I'm like, "Hey, Amelia!" and she says, "Oh. Huh? Yeah, hi ..."  Once during PE we had to sit down and on the way to the gym, she was chatting with me in a BBBBFFFF way. But then when we had to partner up she said with Andrea, Daniela and someone else who I forgot.   I don't know what to do. It's just so weird. Even though now I know she MIGHT be using me (I'm not sure if she really is) it just seems WEIRD. Even for a supposed ##### she was my possibly fake best friend for the whole of last year. It's WEIRD to suddenly switch.   I don't even know if this should be happening. We've only just started 5th grade. Doesn't this WEIRD #### start happening around middle school? Thank you, everyone who will help in advance. P.S. Please include flirting advice. - A Girl Who Might Just Lose Her Possibly Fake Best Friend
reply about 19 hours
Okay I have school today and my hair is not sitting how I want it to. But my mum says it is sitting fine WHEN ITS NOT! SHE IS NOT LISTENING what do i do?
reply about 20 hours

play online games