Kw-logo-holiday

Art Inspired by September 11

Eric Fischl's sculpture, Tumbling Woman, was removed from Rockefeller Center.
Tumbling Woman
Kerry Swank's piece, Freedom, currently hangs in the Pentagon.
Kerry Swank's Freedom

It's been years since the World Trade Towers fell on September 11, 2001, but many people are still trying to deal with the devastation. Some people have decided to deal with their grief - like New York artist, Eric Fischl - through art, music or other creative expression. But where do we draw the line on what's art and what's just plain offensive?

Eric Fischl is the artist responsible for the sculpture Tumbling Woman displayed in Rockefeller Center in New York. Tumbling Woman is supposed to be representative of all those people who either jumped or fell from the Trade Towers. The sculpture drew a ton of criticism and was soon hidden behind curtains and then removed. While some people say this art project was incredibly insensitive, Eric Fischl stands by his sculpture.

"The sculpture was not meant to hurt anybody," Fischl said in a statement. "It was a sincere expression of deepest sympathy for the vulnerability of the human condition. Both specifically towards the victims of Sept. 11 and towards humanity in general."

A similar art display also caused controversy at the Jamaica Center for Arts in New York. This time it was a project of Sharon Paz's. The display, called Falling, was made up of cutouts of falling bodies of various shapes and forms stuck to the windows of the gallery. The piece was supposed to stay up until October 1, 2002 but was taken down on September 23, 2002 after complaints from staff and patrons.

Both artists claim to be trying to help the people of New York heal with these art projects. But how does a statue of a naked woman falling to her death help anyone? Wouldn't it be better to celebrate those people's lives in a less graphic, less morbid way? I'm sure those people do not want to be remembered for their less than glorious end.

The Pentagon chose a piece of artwork titled "Freedom" by Kerry Swank in light of September 11th. Her piece was made five months before the attacks on the Trade Towers but its subject is a perfect example of what the people of America should be celebrating and remembering about the United States.

Have Your Say

Here's what Kidzworld member Brian had to say: "I don't think that it should have been removed. You ask how "Tumbling Woman" can help anyone and wouldn't it be better to celebrate in a less morbid way? You're missing the point of the sculpture. It demonstrates human fragility and confronts tragedy head on. We can't just close our eyes and forget about 9/11. Doing so would just be burying more denial about the tragedy. Art shouldn't just be about the good stuff in life; the bad exists, too. The purpose of art is to portray one's thoughts or reactions (in this case, to the attacks), and the sculpture does just that. It surprises me that it was removed for being too effective."

What do you think about these art pieces? Should they have been removed or kept on display? Add your comment below!

Related Stories
>

readers voted!

Comments

animals-are-cool
its hard to think how many people died
commented: Fri Oct 31, 2014

14misskitty

14misskitty wrote:

My cousin and her husband died in the tower
commented: Tue Oct 28, 2014

niall48

niall48 wrote:

How does this art help anybody. it is sad to think that those people died are remembered by this art
commented: Wed Sep 25, 2013

there are 144 more comments

Please login or register to add comments


like this article?
Sign up now to get more just like it!

latest videos

F1033084741265

9-11 Artwork: Offensive or Not?

  • Yes.
  • No.
  • I'm undecided.

related stories

Micro_greektv_micro
Kidzworld hung out on set with the cast of Greek to get their fun and useful back-to-school tips....
Micro_literacy_micro
September 8 is International Literacy Day. Seems pretty fitting, since kids around the world are ...
Micro_patriot_micro
This day is to honor all those who lost their lives in the 2001 attacks on the World Trade Center...

Random in the forums

sharlene13
sharlene13 posted in General:
hey someone text me 
reply 15 minutes
karacck
karacck posted in General:
YOUR MOOD :HAPPY FAVORITE COLOR :BLUE FAVORITE CARTOON: STEVEN UNIVERSE
reply 19 minutes
SelenaGomezFanGirl
thanks but ill have to check that character cuz i aint know that person!
reply 22 minutes
Miley143
Miley143 posted in General:
"Charulata" wrote: "Miley143" wrote: YOUR MOOD :-  Overly Excited  FAVORITE COLOR:- Black FAVORITE CARTOON:- Well this isn't a cartoon but my favorite movie is The Nightmare Before Christmas  Sorry! You have to tell your favorite cartoon's name! oh I'm sorry well probably  looney tunes?
reply 30 minutes
blackveilbrides15
6 foot 4 
reply 37 minutes

play online games

Hour-of-code-tumb

Codey the troll is lost! Help him avoid obstacles and get back into the computer...

Candy-quest-feature

Your troll is lost! Help it avoid obstacles and get back into the computer.

Fo...

Dragon-dash

Your dragon must return to guard the treasure! Help it gather lost coins and avo...

_thumb_100x100

Shoot blobs with different properties to merge yellow blobs. Your blobs can be r...

1005_cc_kidz_100x100_vlh

Candy's got her candies into a terrible mess, can you help her to sort them out?

Candy-100

A great online version of the famous Candy Crush. This is the best game launched...

_thumb_100x100

Bloons 2 is here! A worthy and awesome sequel at last to our original Bloons gam...

Frostbox_100x100

Explore the world or hang out with friends in your own condo. Get a unique look,...