Kw-logo-smaller

A Girl's Guide to Hunting and Fishing Book Review

Jane started out kick-ass and turned out lame.
Courtesy of Penguin
A Girl's Guide to Hunting and Fishing Book Review - Reviewed by Kidzworld on Dec 27, 2006
( Rating: 4 Star Rating)

A Girl's Guide To Hunting and Fishing introduces Jane, an independent girl in her early teens. Jane starts out an awesome heroine and turns into a doormat - I'm still trying to figure out how.

Author: Melissa Banks

Okay I think I missed a chapter or three in this book of short stories. Girls' Guide opens with the story Advanced Beginners. This story introduces Jane, an independent girl in her early teens[/kwlink]. It is about Jane's first observation of adult relationships. Her brother and his girlfriend come to visit; Jane is awed by the girlfriend and perplexed by her brother's new-found maturity. This story is awesome! I closed my eyes and related to what Jane was experiencing.


Twenties Girl

The next story jumps to Jane in her twenties. Here is the point where another chapter would have been nice, because Jane is now a paranoid girlfriend! How did that happen?! We don't know why, but she is dating a jerk. Why has our heroine morphed into a desperate doormat? As the book continues, Jane continues to turn into a man obsessed freak. As I read, I got increasingly frantic waiting for an explanation or a turnaround. I wanted to yell at her, "Jane, what are you doing? You are a smart person! Save yourself!" Then finally after about 15 years of dating jerks, Jane finally gets it right by meeting a guy, who is sooo obviously not about having a doormat-girlfriend. And what does Jane do to mess it up? She buys a book of dating rules! Argh! There is no doubt in my mind, in real life, this awesome guy would have lost patience after the first date. But he doesn't, maybe cause he's clueless too.


Finding Her Man

Finally our heroine is true to herself, finds her man and the world is well. But I am left wondering why writers feel the need to make their heroine's main plight finding a husband? Helen Fielding did it with Bridget Jones and now Melissa Banks has added to the list of books NOT to read if you are single and happy.


Girls Guide to Hunting and Fishing Rating: 4


Related Stories:

  • Jurassic Park 3 Movie Review
  • Dinosaur :: Book Review
  • Walking With Dinosaurs
  • Get More Book Reviews Here
  • readers voted!

    Comments

    there are 0 comments

    Please login or register to add comments

    share with your friends


    Twitter Facebook MySpace Digg


    like this article?
    get more just like it in your email

    F1024093549468

    Long Distance Relationships - Yes or No?

    • If he/she doesn't go to my school, or live on my block, it's too much effort.
    • It depends on the distance - a few hours away is no biggie.
    • Distance doesn't matter if it's true love!

    related stories

    Random in the forums

    iamalive
    iamalive posted in Say Anything:
    Agreed.
    reply less than a minute
    SugerSprinkledWalrus
    So, I'm not going to go off on a rant, but I do need to say, I HATE SCROLLING DOWN FOR A CENTURY BECAUSE SOME DUDE HAS A PAGE-LONG SIGNATURE. Yes, gifs are cute and funny. Yes, pictures are nice. But twenty of them? We don't need to see your live story told in the form of One Direction. Thank you. Have a nice day. --SSW
    reply 3 minutes
    SugerSprinkledWalrus
    Hey y'all! So school's almost out and I know I'm a little late for this post, but I just wanted to say that you're not invisible. It occured to me today that sometimes being shut out and purposefully ignored can hurt worse than being yelled at or being called names. I know this statement will be a controversial one, but it's what I think. My younger sister and I have been reinacting the Cold War, except I'm the United States and she's the Soviet Union. In other words, I shut her out. And I know it hurts her, yet I can't seem to stop. Her words and actions still effect me and I have the power to sign the treaty, but I don't. It hurts us both and, does it make anything better? No. So the next time you start the silent treatment, think twice about it, because it's hard to get out of! And the next time you're the one being shut out, try to make that treaty and resolve the issue before it just hangs there for a decade. Thanks for reading! And, you're not invisible. --SSW
    reply 14 minutes
    -Kat-
    -Kat- posted in General:
    I almost have 6000 points lolnoidont
    reply 17 minutes
    -Kat-
    -Kat- posted in Food:
    Noooo ewwww. 
    reply 19 minutes

    play online games

    Family-barn100

    Welcome to Family Barn! A game about true country living. Featuring the cutest o...

    Tri_basicintegration_100

    Triviador is a game like no other, merging strategy with trivia. The rich multi...

    1005_cc_kidz_100x100_vlh

    Candy's got her candies into a terrible mess, can you help her to sort them out?

    Goodgame_empire-startscreen-100

    Goodgame Empire is a great strategy title by Goodgame Studios. Build your own ca...

    Owtokidoki100x100

    Explore the world or hang out with friends in your own condo. Get a unique look,...