Kw-logo-holiday

Pledge of Allegiance Debate

A court case in California almost changed the words of the Pledge of Allegiance.
Pledge of Allegiance

Every morning across the United States of America, over 60 million teachers and students recite the Pledge of Allegiance. But, in 2002, a California man named Dr. Michael Newdow, sued the federal and state governments and his daughter's local school board because the words "under God" in the Pledge offended him, as he and his family are atheists (do not believe in God). The California court agreed, saying the Pledge of Allegiance was unconstitutional.

Two years later, on June 14, 2004, the Supreme Court over-ruled the California courts decision - leaving the words "under God" in the constitution for now. The ruling comes on the 50th anniversary of the addition of the words "under God" to the Pledge.

The Issues - Pros and Cons of "under God"

Because it is law for religion and government to be separate, Dr. Michael Newdow took his case to court, and won. Judge Alfred T. Goodwin declared the Pledge to be unconstitutional, but the Supreme Court thought otherwise. Because Dr. Michael Newdow does not have "sufficient custody" of his daughter (Dr. Newdow and his wife are separated, so for now his daughter doesn't live with him full time), the Supreme Court says that Dr. Newdow doesn't have the legal right to sue on his daughter's behalf. Michael Newdow says he will still continue his fight to have the words "under God" removed from the Pledge.

Pledge of Allegiance 101

If you're unfamiliar with the Pledge of Allegiance, here's what it says:
"I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all."

What Does It All Mean?

Children across the United States will continue to say the Pledge of Allegiance as it is written. However, the recent ruling by the Supreme Court does leave things open for others to still challenge the Pledge. If, for instance, Michael Newdow had full custody of his daughter, the result of this court case may have been different.

"Under God" - The History

Many argued that removing the words "under God" would be tampering with American tradition, but the truth is, the phrase "under God" was not added to the Pledge of Allegiance until 1954. During the Cold War, the words were added to separate the United States from the "godless Communists".

What do you think about the Pledge of Allegiance debate? !

  • To find out what Kidzworld members have to say about the Pledge of Allegiance case, click here.

    Related Stories:

  • Flag Day
  • Controversial Religious Art
  • Pokemon Banned
  • More On Religion and Controversy
  • >

    readers voted!

    Comments

    ps3master

    ps3master wrote:

    Nowhere is there suppose dto be religous and governmental seperation,speration of Church and State is meaning that the "State" or Government has no control ove rwho chooses what religion.
    commented: Sat Jul 06, 2013

    ps3master

    ps3master wrote:

    Nowhere is there suppose dto be religous and governmental seperation,speration of Church and State is meaning that the "State" or Government has no control ove rwho chooses what religion.
    commented: Sat Jul 06, 2013

    ps3master

    ps3master wrote:

    It wasboriginaly Under God its gonna stay that way.
    commented: Sat Jul 06, 2013

    there are 7 more comments

    Please login or register to add comments


    like this article?
    Sign up now to get more just like it!

    latest videos

    F1025291062546

    Is God In Or Out?

    • I think the words "under God" should be removed.
    • I want the Pledge to stay just the way it is.
    • I'll wait to see what the court decides.
    • I don't really know what to think.

    related stories

    Random in the forums

    Moonshine Sam
    2 or 3 years
    reply about 1 hour
    Moonshine Sam
    ummm...yeah i don't actually have any filipino friend so... i dont know but i like their food :D yummmy 
    reply about 1 hour
    vokun
    vokun posted in Say Anything:
    shh. people don't even know what and where Philippines is.
    reply about 2 hours
    Mrawsomegamer
    Mrawsomegamer posted in Debating:
    Well, I'm not sure if any of you knew, (I might have told Alpha T, but I don't remember if I did) there was an incident which happened at our school. I was a few doors away when it happened, but a person, who was in her class, stabbed a teacher, who I knew and loved, in front of a group of seniors getting ready for their GCSE's. I remember the screaming and commotion caused as she screamed for her pupils to get out. A girl came into my class, screaming that Mrs Maguire had been stabbed.  We saw our teacher rush out of the room.  That day, we were escorted to lessons by teachers. We weren't allowed to go anywhere unless a teacher told us... We were made to stay at the school the whole day, and we were all so worried. Mrs Maguire was a well lived teacher you see. The teachers told us that an 'incident occurred' and we shouldn't worry. The general public knew she died before us... The press were all over the outside of the school, taking photos of us...  (I don't wanna stray too far from the topic) but the guy who did it does deserve the death penalty. I don't care what the cost is and I don't quite care if I'm honest. He killed a teacher that I knew and loved, and I'm sure you would agree that you'd feel the same in that situation... I do. He only got 20 years, (which is apparently life here in the UK.) :angry
    reply about 2 hours
    -AdorableArmi-
    I love Philippines with all  my heart <3 <3 <3 
    reply about 2 hours

    play online games

    Hour-of-code-tumb

    Codey the troll is lost! Help him avoid obstacles and get back into the computer...

    Candy-quest-feature

    Your troll is lost! Help it avoid obstacles and get back into the computer.

    Fo...

    Dragon-dash

    Your dragon must return to guard the treasure! Help it gather lost coins and avo...

    _thumb_100x100

    Shoot blobs with different properties to merge yellow blobs. Your blobs can be r...

    1005_cc_kidz_100x100_vlh

    Candy's got her candies into a terrible mess, can you help her to sort them out?

    Candy-100

    A great online version of the famous Candy Crush. This is the best game launched...

    _thumb_100x100

    Bloons 2 is here! A worthy and awesome sequel at last to our original Bloons gam...

    Frostbox_100x100

    Explore the world or hang out with friends in your own condo. Get a unique look,...