Kw-logo-smaller

Geography Club Book Review

Geography Club Book Review - Reviewed by Kidzworld on Dec 27, 2006
( Rating: 4 Star Rating)

Brent Hartinger writes about the loneliness and fear of being a gay kid in high school in the teen fiction book, Geography Club, published by Harper Collins.

Author: Brent Hartinger

High school isn't always easy. In fact, most of the time, it's a pretty rough ride. There's trying to fit in, trying to be popular, trying to make the team, trying to pass the test - the list goes on. But, it's even rougher if you're gay. Geography Club is about the tough time of being gay in high school.


Geography Club Members

Russel Middlebrook is your typical, average teen. He's not a nerd, but not a jock. He's not a loser, but not a winner. What he is - without a doubt - is gay. Russel knows it, but no one else does, and he feels like the only gay teen on the planet. Until he finds another gay teen from his high school in a chat room. Turns out it's one of the hottest guys - and biggest jocks - in the school. Then Russel discovers one of his best friends is bi-sexual - and her girlfriend also attends their high school. Looking for a way to bond, they decide to start the Geography Club, an afterschool club where they can - without the rest of the world knowing about it - share the pressures involved in hiding their sexuality.


Geography Club Hits

The book is interesting because it shows you how something that is easy for straight teens (like dating), is super-hard for gay teens. Some of the characters, like school loser Brian Bund and quirky club-joiner Belinda, are really interesting characters. They show how some straight issues can be just as painful and lonely as gay issues. They also are less annyoing and self-involved as characters like Kevin Land or Russel Middlebrook. Min is also a really cool, smart character, but despite being Russel's best friend, she's not in the story much.


Geography Club Misses

This book has all the makings of a compelling and compassionate read, but it just isn't. The storyline moves along too quickly. We don't really get to develop a bond with the gay characters because they are just exposed too easily. It might have been a better read if the whole thing wasn't from Russel's perspective only. It would have been cool to get to know Min or Belinda or Ike a little better and really see their struggles. The way Russel will do anything for his secret boyfriend is just lame.


The Bottom Line

By the end of the book, you do have a better understanding of the characters, but it's the end of the book. Too little too late. And yes, Russel gets a backbone and you actually start to like him again, but again - too little, too late.


Geography Club Rating: 4


Related Stories:

  • Boy Meets Boy Book Review
  • The 411 on Gay Parents
  • Stargirl Book Review
  • 1 Comment

    latest videos

    Gay-sun

    Do You Know Any Gay Poeople?

    • I know peeps who are gay.
    • I don't know anybody who is gay.
    • I think some of my friends are gay.
    • I am gay.

    related stories

    Random in the forums

    TheEnd777
    TheEnd777 posted in Debating:
    "-Karpov-" wrote: "TheEnd777" wrote: The law is NOT about discrimination Being able to discriminate against a certain class of people is exactly what it's about.  "TheEnd777" wrote: Why should a caterer or a florist be forced to serve for a wedding that they believe is wrong and immoral according to their religion? Because they're a  part of an economy where discrimination is not conducive to healthy business or ethical behavior.  So what you are saying is that the rights of the gay people trump the rights of the religious people? In a free enterprise capitalist system, by definition the people have the right to run a business however they see fit. You should be allowed to provide your services to whoever you want, not be forced into providing them to whoever wants them, otherwise it is not freedom, it is dictation.  
    reply 2 minutes
    Ghostling
    Ghostling posted in General:
    I don't remember.
    reply 2 minutes
    deadguy
    deadguy posted in General:
    fjljfdknjklv;,dropkg    <--- that's art.
    reply 5 minutes
    -Karpov-
    -Karpov- posted in Debating:
    "TheEnd777" wrote:The law is NOT about discrimination Being able to discriminate against a certain class of people is exactly what it's about.  "TheEnd777" wrote:Why should a caterer or a florist be forced to serve for a wedding that they believe is wrong and immoral according to their religion? Because they're a  part of an economy where discrimination is not conducive to healthy business or ethical behavior. 
    reply 6 minutes
    TheEnd777
    TheEnd777 posted in Debating:
    "lelnah" wrote:America is SUPPOSEDLY the country of freedom. Of course this is wrong! VERY wrong! So it's okay to force a florist or a caterer to provide for a wedding that violates their religion? Or to force a store to employ someone even if their personal values go against them? 
    reply 10 minutes

    play online games